|
Basic InformationLookupsLatest NewsAs U.S. Measles Outbreaks Spread, Why Does 'Anti-Vax' Movement Persist?Health Tip: Know Your Family's Medical HistoryDisrupted Sleep Plagues Hospital Patients, But New Program Might HelpClimate Change Already Hurting Human Health, Review ShowsCalling All Blood Donors …Radiation Doses From CT Scans Vary WidelyCan Herbal Drug Kratom Kill?Health Tip: Use Medical Devices SafelyDon't Let Holiday Season Stress Worsen Your Allergies, AsthmaA Family Tragedy Highlights Carbon Monoxide DangerPhysical Therapy Can Help You Avoid Opioids When Joint Pain StrikesEczema Can Drive People to Thoughts of Suicide: StudyHospitalizations Rising Among the HomelessMillions of Americans Still Breathing Secondhand Smoke: ReportMany Americans Unaware of Promise of Targeted, 'Personalized' Medicine: PollMost Americans Lie to Their DoctorsWhat's Best for Babies With Recurring Ear InfectionsAfter a Spouse's Death, Sleep Woes Up Health RisksConcussion Tied to Suicide RiskMajor Injuries Take a Toll on Mental HealthNew Cholesterol Guidelines Focus on Personalized ApproachHome Health-Care Tests: Proceed With CautionU.S. Hospitals Making Headway Against InfectionsHard Arteries Hard on the Aging Brain?Widely Used Antipsychotics May Not Ease Delirium in ICUNew Nerve Stimulation Technique Might Relieve Back PainAHA: Stiffening of Blood Vessels May Point to Dementia RiskHeart Defects, Sleep Apnea a Deadly Mix for InfantsDozens of Medical Groups Join Forces to Improve Diagnoses1 in 12 Americans Lives With Debilitating Chronic PainUrgent Care Centers Ease ER Burden in U.S.AHA: Heart Health Research of 9/11 Survivors Slowly Realized, 17 Years LaterAHA: Wildfire Smoke Threatens Health of Those Near and FarStem Cells Restore Some Vision in Blind MiceDialysis Linked to Dementia in SeniorsHealth Tip: Making an Emergency CallEye Disease Link to Alzheimer's SeenPreschoolers' Parents May Be Unprepared to Treat AsthmaHealth Woes Hit 1 in 7 Babies Exposed to Zika in U.S. TerritoriesSprained Ankle? Opioid Rx More Likely in Some States Than OthersOpioids Before Joint Replacement Tied to Worse RecoveryIn the ICU, Patients' Relatives Often Mum About Care ConcernsObesity Adds to Burden of Traumatic Brain InjuryWarming Climate, More AC -- and More Unhealthy Smog AheadIs That iPad a Pain in the Neck?Severe Stress May Send Immune System Into OverdriveMarriage Is Good Medicine for the HeartHealth Tip: Breathe Easier in a Volcano ZoneTips for Handling a Medical EmergencyThe ER or Urgent Care? Questions and AnswersVideosScreening for Heart DiseaseWhat is Lupus and Who Gets It?Could You Have PrediabetesDifferent Types of Anemia Resist Taking Unnecessary AntibioticsTaking Energy Drinks to Heart Weathering MigrainesCrohn's vs Ulcerative Colitis Six Things You Need to Know About EbolaHeadache or Migraine?Preventing Pre-Diabetes Getting Radiation During Breast Cancer SurgeryWhat You Don’t Know About AFib May Hurt YouAntibiotics Aren’t Always The AnswerAdult Onset Asthma Healthy Eating for a DiabeticYounger People Slower to get Diabetes Diagnosis Recognizing Type 1 & Type 2 Diabetes Diabetes: Know Your NumbersCold or Allergy? What You REALLY Need to Know about EbolaSignals You May be Ready for Joint Replacement Slowing the Spread of Superbugs TelehealthIs it Anxiety or a Heart Condition?E.Coli FactsDiabetes Doesn’t Disappear Get Smart About Antibiotics: For Patients and Parents Brain Nourishment to Prevent StrokesWhen Do You Need an Antibiotic? Are You Having a Heart Attack? The Journey of Palliative Care: Putting Quality Back Into Life Diabetes- What You Don't Know Could Hurt YouWhy Second Opinions Are Good for PatientsFollow Your Gut: Microbiomes and AgingTreating Migraines Reading the Stroke SignsBelly Fat Danger Revealed Prevention and Control of Skin Cancer Tackling ConcussionsCarpal Tunnel: Who Gets It? Asthma 101 Health and Wellness: Taking a Stand Against Sitting Back Pain: Oh My Aching Back Itching for Answers: Testing Your Allergy IQ Keeping Kidneys Safe - Know How Medicines Affect the Kidneys The Role of Family History in Breast Cancer What is Diabetes Do your part to stop the spread of flu at home Could You Have Prediabetes? Are You at Risk for Kidney Disease? I Have High Cholesterol.. What Should I Do?What Does "Bad" Cholesterol Do?Five Things to Know About MeaslesCeliac Disease 101 - An OverviewAsthma in Children: Working Together to Get it Under ControlSeven Ways to Improve your Arthritis PainTop 3 Tips for a Healthy Heart in the New YearDo your Symptoms Add Up to DiabetesBreakdown on AFib Non-Smokers Getting Lung Cancer Connecting with a Cardiologist A Hot Treatment for AsthmaWho Needs a Flu Vaccine?Keeping Up with Heart FailureTurning the Immune System Against Lung Cancer Dealing with Menopause, Naturally Managing Chronic Disease Pays Off Beyond the Data -- Dengue and Chikungunya in Our Backyard: Preventing Aedes Mosquito-Borne Diseases Peanut Allergies: A Bigger Threat to Kids with Asthma Liver Disease and Anxiety and DepressionImproving Muscle HealthStroke Prevention Diagnosis and Treatment Options Webinar Cancer Clinical Trials: What is a Clinical Trial? Zika VirusYoung People May Need Colonoscopy Working to Eliminate Measles Around the Globe Colorectal cancer: A disease of development Huntington Disease Facts about the Measles (MMR) VaccineLove Your Heart. Everyday Tips to Keep Your Heart Healthy and Strong Breast Cancer Risk And Lifestyle Strategies to Reduce ItDoes my Child Have Asthma and How Should it be Treated? Superbugs Moving From Hospitals to HomesInfectious Disease Expert Explains MERSNew Treatment Option for Women with Advanced Breast CancerAn Evidence-Based Approach to Youth Sports ConcussionsHow to Prevent and Detect Skin CancerConcussion Guide for Parents How Your Immune System WorksHow the Digestive System WorksLiving with Lactose Intolerance Avian Flu Faster Healing for Abdominal Surgery The Road to Zero: CDC’s Response to the West African Ebola Epidemic, 2014–2015 Avoiding Heat Exhaustion and Heatstroke Preventing Salmonella and E. coliAdults: Do You Know What Vaccines You Need?Seasonal AllergiesGame Change in Treating Heart Attack Beyond the Data Update -- Climate Change and HealthIncreased Rates of Pregnancy Complications in Women with Celiac DiseaseBehavioral Health Response to EbolaLearning & cognitive difficulties in children: Challenges after a head injury, including concussion Low Testosterone Often Spells Low Bone Density WHO: Prevent hepatitis Allergy OverloadVaccines for Lyme Disease - Past, Present, and FutureBecoming a Living Liver Donor: Evaluation, Risks, and Recovery Breaking Down Hip Fractures Working on Your Back Pain The Heartburn-Asthma Connection Stop the Spread of Antibiotic ResistanceVaccinations and ImmunizationsInfluenza, an Unpredictable Threat Sport Concussions in Youth: Community Guide for Education, Treatment and Research Hyper-Hypo Thyroid, What’s the Diff? Reading the Warning Signs of Parkinson’s Older Americans Preventing DiabetesAsthma UpdateGet Vaccinated and Prevent MeaslesFamily History and Heart Disease Breast Feeding and Gluten Introduction: What Research Tells UsRashes: A Brief Overview of the Different Causes Back to School: Sick Kids - Should They Stay or Should They Go? Preventive Cardiology Pumping up Heart Warnings on Pain Relievers Pre-Diabetes a Chance for PreventionCancer - What does it mean that a chemical causes an increase in cancer risk?CDC Urges Sepsis Awareness Managing Celiac Disease Through Diet Learn the ABCs of Ticks with Dr. Bobbi Pritt New Stem Cell Therapy for Crohn’s FistulaMale Urethral Stricture Disease: Signs, Symptoms and Treatment Trends and Racial Differences in Celiac DiseaseObesity Can Have Implications Specific to Women Zika Virus 101Coping With Stress: Cognitive-Behavioral Stress Reduction What are the Risk Factors for Kidney Disease? Can Hypnotics Help Celiac Disease Patients Get a Good Night’s Sleep?Aspirin 411: What the New Guidelines Mean Kids With Asthma Who Are Exposed To Secondhand Smoke Have Twice As Many Hospitalizations Ankle Sprains—Pain Free Does Not Mean Normal Sport Concussions in YouthGenetics For Preventive Cardiology ‘Creeping Fat’ May Contribute to IBDWhat’s Triggering Your Allergies? Is There a Link Between Celiac Disease and Heart Disease?Systematic approach helps prevent ACL injury in athletesLupus: Your body's immune system attacks your own tissues and organs Psoriasis and beyond: targeting the IL-17 pathway A Review of Treatments Available for Celiac DiseaseHow to handwash? With soap and water Disparities in early childhood obesity: Risk factors and possible solutionsRecognize the Signs and Symptoms of StrokeBone Up on Calcium Lose That Burning Feeling (Heartburn)Thyroid Nodules and Thyroid Cancer: What You Need to KnowZika virus - Questions and answersHeartburn or Something More Serious?Microcephaly and Zika virus infection - Questions and answers Celiac Disease: What Is a Gluten-Free Diet Hepatitis C Lessons on a ChalkboardZika Virus: Four Myths and What You Need to Know Is It a Cold or Allergies? What is Lupus and Who Gets It? 5 tips to keep your gut microbiome healthyLungs & Respiratory System How Your Thyroid Impacts Your Weight Don't Underestimate the Dangers of Heat Is it cold, flu or allergies? How Fibromyalgia and Chronic Fatigue Are Related Kids and Common Infections LinksBook Reviews |
| |
by Sheila Rothman and David Rothman Pantheon Books, 2003 Review by Alex Sager on Jun 3rd 2004
Bioethicians
commonly distinguish between "treatment" and "enhancement".
The doctor's proper role is to treat diseases or conditions, returning patients
to a normal state. Treatment is necessary or, in the case of less serious
conditions, highly desirable. Enhancement, on the other hand, appears
gratuitous, going beyond naturally set limits. Whatever we may think about cosmetic
surgery, botox or the use of hormones to increase athletic performance, doctors
hardly have an obligation to carry out these procedures.
This
distinction is not merely academic, since insurance policies usually cover
treatments, but not enhancements. This provides an incentive to shift the
boundary between treatment and enhancement. Furthermore, a little reflection
shows that this line is blurry and often controversial. For example, is chronic
shyness simply a matter of having certain personality traits or a psychological
condition that needs to be treated? What about being extremely short, but not
having any recognized disease, such as a growth hormone deficiency? And to cite
a few examples, obesity, hyperactivity and depression, once considered outside
the domain of medicine, are now the focus of treatments.
Sheila
and David Rothman explore this distinction in their fascinating history of
medical enhancement The Pursuit of Perfection. They survey the history
of estrogen replacement therapy, anti-aging medicine (including testosterone
supplements for normal, older men), liposuction and growth hormone, in each
case showing how a combination of social forces, economic interests and
institutional pressures encourage the spread of risky, often dubious practices.
The Rothmans document how, time and again, enhancement technologies become
available despite the fact that their efficacy is far from established and
their dangers far from negligible.
The
bulk of the book covers the rise of hormone replacement therapy, which provides
a template for other enhancement technologies. The Rothmans show how hormone
replacement therapy shifted over the last century from largely ineffective
anti-aging medicine to a recommended treatment for middle-aged women.
Researchers redefined menopause, once considered a natural, inevitable
condition, as a disease, something to be cured. Post-menopausal women are
defined as "neuters", suffering from an unnatural state to be
remedied by estrogen supplementation. Along with these sweeping claims about
the nature of femininity, doctors and pharmaceutical companies made often
unsubstantiated claims about the effect of estrogen on osteoporosis, mental
health and Alzheimer's disease. While largely accepting the potentially
positive effects, they downplayed or ignored the real possibility that it might
cause cancer.
Not
surprisingly, economic factors also played an important role in the spread of
these technologies. This isn't in itself disturbing, but, as the Rothmans show,
the medical profession largely accepted and promoted the interests of
pharmaceutical companies when it should have been providing checks and
balances. Warnings and protests were largely ignored, while selected
gynecologists received lucrative "research grants" from pharmaceutical
companies to endorse their products. The influence of the pharmaceutical
companies extended to the scientific community, where sympathetic researchers
were invited to give papers at company sponsored conferences. These papers were
then published in special volumes, circumventing the process of peer review and
giving products "scientific" legitimacy. These, and other
questionable partnerships between researchers, doctors and pharmaceutical
companies, were not considered out of the ordinary, despite the obvious
conflict of interest.
If it
weren't for the real risks some of these technology, pharmaceutical companies
could simply argue that they were merely attempting to fulfill an enormous
demand. After all, society values youth and beauty. Though we might question
the emphasis placed on these qualities, criticism would be misplaced if it
turned out that these hormone replacement therapy was overwhelming beneficial
or harmless. But this isn't the case. In July 2002, a study funded under the US
Women's Health Initiative was abruptly stopped because the 65,000 women
receiving hormone replacement therapy had significantly higher levels of
coronary heart disease, strokes, pulmonary blood clots and breast cancer.
Though hormone replacement therapy did seem to have a positive effect on
colorectal cancer and hip fractures, the Journal of the American Medical
Association explicitly recommended against the use estrogen/progestin for
preventing chronic disease.
The
sections on liposuction – which has higher death rate than many non-elective
surgical procedures – testosterone, growth hormone, genetic modification and
anti-aging technology follow a similar pattern, which can be reduced to a few
factors. First, there is the technological imperative: despite the protests,
technology that can be developed will be developed. Even if we attempt to
restrain research, the thin line between enhancement and diseases makes this
difficult. Often, research may have multiple or ambiguous applications,
allowing enhancement technologies to be developed despite protests. At the same
time, heavy handed legislation could very well prevent important research for
preventing disease from being carried out. Second, economic factors encourage
this research. Doctors, scientists and pharmaceutical companies will continue
to work hand in hand because it pays very well. A third, related factor
concerns social pressures. As mentioned above, cosmetic surgery is a
multimillion dollar enterprise because there is a market for it. Finally,
people come to accept once controversial technologies. In vitro
fertilization, now a generally accepted practice, once received the same
controversy as cloning. The might can be said for hormone replacement therapy
and liposuction.
If
there is a fault with the Rothman's book, it is the fact that it doesn't
provide much guidance for people trying to think critical about enhancement
technologies. In fact, one is left with the feeling that these technologies,
given our contemporary zeitgeist, are inevitable. All of these economic,
social and technological factors lead to treatments becoming available before
they have been sufficiently tested. What, if anything, does their study tell us
about the distinction between treatment and enhancement? How should governments
and concerned citizens react when faced with this technology? What are the
implications of their study for genetic modification, cloning and other
technologies that may soon become common place? These and other questions are
left largely unanswered.
Still,
this book is recommended to anyone who wants to grasp the history of medical
enhancement and reflect on its future. It provides a valuable survey of a
fascinating period that each year becomes more relevant.
© 2004 Alex
Sager
Alex Sager
writes about himself:
I'm a philosopher and writer, married to a Mexican lawyer.I am
currently doing a Ph.D. in philosophy at L'Université de Montréal. In my thesis
I am proposing a model of our moral psychology combining the insights of
cognitive science, developmental psychology, evolutionary psychology and other
disciplines. I believe that most philosophers are still using psychology from
the 18th century, ignoring many of the recent scientific advances, and suggest
that there is evidence our minds contain a number of innate, distinct faculties
that allow us to make moral judgments in different domains.
|